Sheila baum.png
Biographical Information
Full name: Sheila Baumgartner
Gender: Female
Ailment: Persistent Genital Arousal Disorder
Occupation(s): Yoga Instructor (formerly)
Status: Deceased
Nickname(s): Orgasm Lady (by Zayday)
Relationship Information
Family: Unnamed husband (ex-husband)
Relationships: Unnamed husband (ex-husband)
Killer: Wes Gardner
Doctors: Dr. Cassidy Cascade
Other Information
Interests: Yoga
Series Information
Season(s): Season Two
Episode count: 1
Only appearance: Handidates
Portrayed by: Cheri Oteri
I am in Hell. That's my secret.
—Sheila to Cathy about her constant orgasms[src]

Sheila Baumgartner is a minor character on Season Two of Scream Queens. She was a patient at C.U.R.E, diagnosed with Persistent Genital Arousal Disorder, characterized by having spontaneous and uncontrollable orgasms. After being cured, she was decapitated by the Green Meanie.

She is portrayed by Cheri Oteri.



Sheila is revealed to have Persistant Genital Arousal Disorder,  causing her to have spontaneous and uncontrollable orgasms. She later has a fight with Chamberlain after taking antidepressants, who pushes her head against the window. Sadie Swenson and Dr. Cassidy Cascade become closer as they figure out why Sheila has developed this ailment. Cascade later explains that Sheila popped her hips out of place while doing a yoga pose. Together, Sadie, and Cassidy find a way to pop her hip back into place and cure her. Sheila is later seen telling Chamberlain and Zayday Williams that she is grateful and plans to put the hospital on the map. Her smile slowly disappears when she spots the Green Meanie killer, who throws a hand scythe toward her, cutting swiftly through her throat, decapitating and killing her. Her head lands on Chamberlain's cart nearby.

Later, when Zayday and Special Agent Denise Hemphill transport Hester Ulrich to the hospital, Zayday mentions that the Green Meanie chopped the "orgasm lady's" head off.

Lovin the D

Hester decides to call a Green Meanie summit, inviting Ingrid, Cassidy, and Wes to come together to discuss the past and future plans for murder. To get everyone on the same page, Hester plans a game called "Who Killed Who?" and reveals a board filled with pictures of each of the various murder victims. Hester then points to a picture of Sheila, to which Wes takes credit for her murder, explaining that he was extremely angry at the time, after having just visited Grace at the asylum.


After Sheila is cured, Zayday and Chamberlain escort her out of the hospital, and Chamberlain gives her a balloon. Sheila tells them that she has notified the authorities about her wonderful treatment at C.U.R.E. However, before she can leave, the Green Meanie appears and throws a scythe right through her throat, decapitating Sheila. Her head lands on Chamberlain's cart, after spraying blood all over the walls.


Season Two (1/10)


  • Her ailment brought Cassidy and Chanel #3 closer together.
  • She is the second victim of the Green Meanie who was killed by decapitation.
  • She shares the same last name as Brian Baumgartner, the actor who portrayed the detective Chad hired, Richard.
  • She was the first victim of Wes Gardner as the Green Meanie.



Green Meanie Victims
←Previous Next→
Randal Tristan St. Pierre
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.