Since Cassidy was revealed as one of the killers, I decided to make this to analyze and theorize what can be attributed to him so far. This is just my take on everything. Feel free to state your theories below in the comment section. Updated weekly, to have more accurate information.
Who did what?[]
- 1986 Halloween massacre:
- Lynn Johnstone's phone call: It was probably Jane. As far as we know, at least right now, is that there is only one baby in Jane's belly, Cassidy. So, this phone call would likely be Jane, or Ingrid Hoffel, who might be Jane's (undoubtedly) older sister.
- Catherine Hobart's murder: The killer was possibly Cassidy, because he became one of the Green Meanies to, in a nutshell, make his mother Jane, proud of him (WHCH IS DUMB AS F**K, BECAUSE JANE PRESUMABLY ALREADY KILLED EVERYONE IN 1986, SO WHY DOES SHE STILL WANT REVENGE NOW, HUH? SENDING YOUR SON OFF, WHO THE F**K DOES THAT TO THEIR KID???????!!!! *deep breath* Sorry abput that. Got carried away there.) The viewer can hear these lyrics in the song that the killer plays.
- Libby "Chanel #5" Putney's attack: Whoever killed Catherine did this, it happened during Catherine's murder.
- Dean Catreen "Cathy" Munsch's attack: Pending. Cassidy was there, so it was the second or third killers.
- Tyler's murder: Pending. This perhaps wasn't Cassidy, because assuming Brock isn't one of the killers, Cassidy was with him having a competition over who was more handsome in fashionable clothes.
- Randal's murder: Pending. This could have easily been Cassidy though, but the second and (maybe) third killer(s) could have easily been the one to do it.
- Sheila Baumgartner's murder: Pending. Still could have been Cassidy, but the second and (maybe) third killer(s) could have easily been the one to do it. Cassidy potentially likes Zayday (watch Scream Again), so this could have been him.
- Special Agent Denise Hemphill's attack:
- Drugging the water at a Halloween party: Cassidy was at the party, so he could not have done this.
- "Chanel #5"s attack: Pending.
- Denise's murder: Pending.
- Party Guests's murders: Both two or all three of the killers could have done this, due to how quickly it was done.
- Tristan "Chanel Pour Homme" St. Pierre's murder: Pending. Any of th three killes could do this.
- Midge "Chanel #11"'s murder: Pending. Definitely not Cassidy though. He was heading to his mother's house. This death, however, makes Hester more suspicious than ever, because of what happened right before this.